At Statler's Cafe, Venable met Sheriff John Hunt. Hunt told her to leave Norman alone and that he didn't want any trouble. Venable ignored him and spoke with Norman anyway. She suggested to him that some people might tend to blame him for the recent disappearance of Emma Spool. Norman left before giving her much information and asked her not to speak with him again.
Later, Venable met Duane Duke at a bar and paid him to feed her any useful information about Norman. She did some research in old issues of the Fairvale Inquirer and discovered that Emma Spool had murdered Norman's father and kidnapped him as a child.
While snooping at the Bates House, Venable found the laid out corpse of Maureen Coyle. She was briefly pursued by Norman but she convinced him that Spool was not his real mother and Norman broke down and destroyed Spool's corpse. He was then arrested.